quinta-feira, 3 de junho de 2010



A new sentence or passage should be read through completely, several

times if necessary, so as to see all its words in context.


As you read, register mentally the ending of every word so as to

recognise how the words in the sentence relate to one another.

Rule 3

Recognise the way in which the sentence is structured: its Main

Clause(s), subordinate clauses and phrases. Read them in sequence to

achieve this recognition and re-read the sentence as often as necessary,

without translating it.


Now look up unfamiliar words in the dictionary; and once you know

what all the words can mean, re-read the Latin to improve your grasp

of the context and so clarify what the words in this sentence do mean.


If translating, translate only when you have seen exactly how the

sentence works and what it means. Do not translate in order to find

out what the sentence means. Understand first, *then* translate.


a. Once a subordinate clause or phrase is begun, it must be

completed syntactically before the rest of the sentence can proceed.

b. When one subordinate construction embraces another, the

embraced one must be completed before the embracing one can


c. A Main Clause must be completed before another Main Clause can



Normally the words most emphasised by the author are placed at the

beginning and end, and all the words in between contribute to the

overall sense, including those forming an embraced or dependent



The words within two or more word-groups are never mixed up



All the actions in a narrative sentence are narrated in the order in

which they occurred.


Analytical sentences are written with phrases and clauses in the order

that is most logical to the author. The sequence of thought is

signposted by the placing of word-groups and key words.

RULE 11 (advisory)

Practise reading Latin regularly, and as often as possible, applying the

Reading Rules throughout.

[A Roman baker’s decem, obviously!]


1 The Romans Didn’t Know English (this rule is pronounced


Since they didn’t know English, Latin is not ‘hidden English’ in

form or vocabulary or grammar. Don’t treat Latin sentences as though

they are in the same word order and layout as English. If they are now

and then, it’s entirely accidental. See Point 2.

2 a Don’t try to find an English meaning for each separate Latin

word, to see if accumulating the separate words in English gives the

meaning of the sentence. This method thinks of a Latin sentence as

actually Hidden English, and yet TRiDiKEe.

b Don’t believe that a Latin sentence is simply equivalent to

English words in a mixed-up order, either. TRiDiKEe.

3 a Phrases, subordinate clauses, and main clauses are all Word-


This is a really important concept.

Word-Groups are as crucial in a sentence as the individual

words. No, they are more crucial.

b The arrangement of word-groups in a sentence is crucial to the


c The order of words within a Latin word-group obeys logical

patterns. Always.

d The order of word-groups in a sentence also obeys logical

patterns. Always.

e You can *train your eyes* to recognise all these patterns, which

are fundamental to the meaning of the sentence. This is how Romans

sight-read Latin. (It is also how we sight-read English.)

f Read and re-read each sentence so as to understand its structure

and its constructions, before you start to translate it.

4 a Each word in a sentence tells you about the grammar and sense

of the words around it. Therefore each word is a *signpost* to other


b The endings of the words are as important as the beginnings.

The endings tell you the grammar of the sentence, i.e. how the words

are related to one another. Motto: ‘ T h e E n d i n g s C o m e

F i r s t . ’

5 How to recognise a subordinate clause word-group:

- It has to start with a conjunction like cum, ut, postquam or the like, or

with a relative word like qui.

- It must contain at least 1 finite verb, i.e. a verb with a subject.

(Sometimes the subject is implied, not given as a separate word—e.g.

libros lego.)

- It cannot form a sentence by itself, but is subordinate to a main

clause. Sometimes the main clause is implied but not given: e.g. Cur

fles?—Quia capitis dolorem habeo. (= [fleo] quia c.d.h.)

- It obeys Point 7 a-d, like all word-groups.

6 How to recognise a phrase:

a A phrase is a word-group that does not have a finite verb. A


[i] may be governed by a preposition, e.g. ex urbe, ab urbe condita,

propter gaudium, in Britanniam, ad urbem videndam, multa cum laude

[ii] may consist of words describing a person, thing or event

mentioned nearby, e.g. urbem ingressus, librum legentes, capillis longissimis,

multis annis, maximae pulchritudinis (attached to puella, for example)

[iii] may be an Ablative Absolute phrase, a gerundival phrase of

purpose, or the like. E.g. Cicerone consule, senatu vocato, ad urbem

pulcherrimam aedificandam, pacis petendae causa

b You can easily recognise a phrase if it starts with a preposition,

but to recognise other phrases you must practise Point 3 a—f.

7 a A word-group of any kind (main clause, subordinate clause, or

phrase), once it has begun, has to be grammatically finished, before the

writer can continue with the rest of the sentence whether this is short

or long. [This statement is an example in English]

For the same reason, a sentence must be grammatically

completed before the next one can start.

b The only exception to 7a is that one word-group can ‘embrace’

another one. E.g. Cicero, qui olim consul erat, nunc in senatum raro venit.

But 7a still applies: the embraced word-group must be grammatically

completed, before the writer can go back to the ‘embracing’ wordgroup.

c Note carefully that 7a & 7b are unbreakable rules in Latin,

for 7b is not really an exception to 7a: the content of an ‘embraced’

word-group is part of the Message of the embracing word-group. On

Message, see Point 9.

d A Latin phrase can ‘embrace’ a subordinate clause, and a

subordinate clause can ‘embrace’ a phrase. E.g. urbe quae magna erat

condita, and ut Romam multis post annis iterum videret.

e If one main clause embraces a second, the second one has to be

in brackets or between long dashes.

8 a In narrative Latin sentences, all the events are reported in the

proper event order, even when the various events are stated in various

types of word-groups.

b In descriptive (non-narrative) Latin sentences, the various wordgroups

are written in the order that seems most logical to the author.

9 In Latin, every sentence carries a Message. The Message is not

always given by just the grammar and vocabulary of the sentence: it

also depends on the context around the sentence, the choice of words

in the sentence and the placing of them. The Message is as important

as the grammar and vocabulary.

Nenhum comentário:

Postar um comentário